3 hours later, I felt some slight burning, but nothing painful. I washed my hands with dish soap and the burning went away.
Next morning, I woke up and took a shower, about 10 min after my shower, my fingers were on FIRE!!!! Starting to panic, this needed to stop. So I went to my go to person, Google. After searching for "how to stop jalapeno burning?" I found a web forum with may different solutions.
Try #1: Cover your hands in milk/oatmeal. I have this lotion called MILK, it is the best lotion in the world, and I thought it would work because it is dried milk solids and oat protein combined in a thick luxurious and moisturizing lotion. Well the burning sensation got worse after applying the lotion. So DO NOT USE for soothing jalapeno burning, but I highly recommend it for everyday use.
Try #2: Use a fat: Oil or Butter. I used olive oil, I poured it all over my hands and rubbed it in as much as I could, but once again the burning got worse.
The Solution: Baking Soda! I wiped all of the olive oil off my hands, and then rinsed my hands so they were a little wet, and then coated my hands in baking soda. I felt cooling almost right away, but the burning was not gone immediately. I sat over the sink for about 30 min (boring!), but finally the burning was gone. Phew! I rinsed my hands again, and I was able to get back to work.
Going forward I am going to stick to using gloves!